Episode III Reviews

   2

Episode III Reviews

Well upon looking for new news, or things on Episode III I came across some more reviews for thoes who are interested.

First one comes from Premier Magazine

Second one comes from Rolling Stone

Lastly, if you like to hear the Ebert and Roeper review it will be up Monday.

Alls I can say is, from reading the comics, and the book. Its going to be one incredible movie

Let Darkness Reign

OP Zekk

Magistrate to the Herald

The Rolling Stone gave it a pretty harsh review.

Peter Travers comments are totally biased. I am an OT myself, but such harsh criticism is uncalled for. It demonstrates his total lack of understanding of the true nature of Lucus' vision. His prejudice has totally blinded him to the fact that the PT has it moments, non in comparison with the OT but sufficient to draw parallel. It is obvious that he lacks any sense of being, as he criticizes the actors on a personal level (that is criticize their acting while using words of praise for their physical appearence..Portman etc) Its obvious that his opinion originates from below the waist as that he has no particilar positive opinion of Lucus' new creations.

If lucas kept up to the style of the OT, we would be criticizing him for lack of vision or repeating the same old story. The PT is a new look, and with out it we can draw no comparison. Thus I say that the PT including ROTS are ideal in the fact that they give us leave to draw a comparison and connects loose ends that were other wise left unfullfilled. To me that is all that is needed.

Thats my two cents.

You need to be logged in to post comments